Disclosure, family communication context, and child outcomes after

Disclosure, family communication context, and child outcomes after

Disclosure, family communication context, and child outcomes after infertility treatment
Martha A. Rueter, PhD , Jennifer Connor, PhD , Lauri Pasch , Kayla Anderson, MA , Ascan F. Koerner, PhD , Mark Damario






Family Social Science, University of Minnesota, bCommunity Psychology, Counseling, and Family Therapy, St. Cloud State University,
University of California, San Francisco, d Communication Studies, University of Minnesota, eObstetrics, Gynecology and Womens Health, University of Minnesota

Disclosure of assisted reproductive technology (ART) conception to
children may involve parents discussing personal, sensitive topics with
their children like parents infertility, sexual reproduction, and the childs
conception occurring in a laboratory. Parents who conceived using donor
gametes have the added challenge of telling children about their genetic
origins (Scheib et al., 2003). Understandably, parents often report
uncertainty about raising these topics with children (Blake et al., 2010;
Daniels et al., 2011; Gross et al., 2004; Rauscher & Fine, 2012).
Most ART research does not consider family communication context
when examining disclosure outcomes. Yet, theory (Petronio, 2002) and
empirical findings (Caughlin & Afifi, 2004; Caughlin & Petronio, 2004;
Merrill & Afifi, 2012) suggest that a parents approach to discussing
personal information could moderate the effect of disclosure on parent
and child outcomes. E.g., some families allow an open flow of personal
information among family members. Others strictly control access to
private information, sharing infrequently in limited amounts. Available
research suggests that in this kind of restricted communication context
disclosure may negatively affect parent-child satisfaction and child
adjustment. (Caughlin, 2003; Caughlin and Afifi, 2004; Petronio, 2002).
Research also shows that relationship satisfaction is a proximal
outcome of disclosure (Collins and Miller, 1994) and parent-child
relationship satisfaction predicts child adjustment (Overbeek et al.,
2007). Therefore, we hypothesized that, among families with a restricted
communication context, disclosure of ART conception relates negatively
to parent-child relationship satisfaction and through this association, has
an indirect, negative effect on child adjustment.

Research Question &
Research Question
Does family communication context moderate the association
between disclosure of ART conception and parent-child
relationship satisfaction, and does this interaction indirectly
relate to child adjustment?
H1: Communication context moderates the association between
disclosure and parent-child satisfaction such that, in a restricted
communication context, disclosure of ART conception
negatively relates to parent-child satisfaction.
H2: In a restricted communication context, disclosure of ART
conception indirectly and negatively relates to child adjustment,
through is association with parent-child satisfaction.

Families (n = 216) were recruited from a university reproductive endocrinology clinic in the Midwest. Eligible families
had at least one parent with at least one child born between 1998 2004, who was conceived via IVF, ICSI, or IUI.
Parents were mostly heterosexual (96.8%) and mostly White (95.8%), with median annual household incomes of
$100,000 $150,000. Participating families included n = 312 children (Mage = 8.48 years, SD = 1.43).

Disclosure of conception method. Parents reported disclosure of conception method by responding yes or no to
the question, Does your child know that s/he was conceived by ART?
Communication context. Communication context was defined as a parents tendency to avoid talking about topics s/
he disapproves of or sees as inappropriate for discussion. Parents reported how much they agreed with two items
(1=disagree completely, 7=agree completely): (1) If I don't approve of it, I don't want to know about it and (2) I often
say things like There are some things that just shouldn't be talked about.
Parent-child relationship satisfaction. Measured using an adapted version of the Huston Marital Opinion
Questionnaire (Caughlin & Afifi, 2004; Huston & Vangelisti, 1991) which consists of 11 semantic differential-type
items beginning with I would describe my relationship as . . . and ending with two opposing options (e.g.,
rewarding vs. disappointing) scaled from 1 to 7.
Child behavioral adjustment. Parents reported childrens behavioral adjustment using the Child Behavior Checklist
(Achenbach & Rescorla, 2001). The child behavioral adjustment variable was created by summing two CBCL subscales
(rule-breaking behavior, aggressive behavior; = .75).
Parent emotional state. Method bias from using parent self-report for all variables was addressed by controlling for
parents emotional state. Feelings of depression and anxiety were reported using the Internalizing subscale of the
Adult Self Report (Achenbach & Rescorla, 2003).
Child demographics. Parents reported the childs age, sex (female = 1, male = 2), and donor status. Donor status was
coded as 1 for children conceived using donor egg, donor sperm, or both donor egg and donor sperm (n = 41).
Nondonor children (donor status = 0) were conceived using the intended parents gametes.

Figure 1. Association between disclosure and parent-child satisfaction
in a restricted compared to open communication context

Parents reported high parent-child satisfaction (M = 6.42, SD = .65) and
few child behavior (M = 3.03, SD = 4.33). Also, parent-child satisfaction
and behavior adjustment were correlated (r = -.53, t = 7.31, p < .001), and disclosure was unrelated to parent-child satisfaction and child behavioral adjustment in the full sample (Table, 1). We estimated the hypothesized associations using structural equation modeling. Model results supported the hypothesized moderator effect (b = -.18, 95% CI = -.27 - -.09, b = -.24, t = -3.37, p = .001). As shown in Figure 1, in families with open communication, disclosure was unrelated to parent-child relationship satisfaction and negatively related to parent-child satisfaction in families with restricted communication. The hypothesized indirect effect was also supported (b = .59, 95% CI = .25 - .93, b = .12, t = 2.85, p = .004). This indirect effect means that in families with restricted communication, disclosure negatively related to child adjustment, through its association with parent-child satisfaction. Table 1. Correlations among study variables Measure 1. Communication Context 2. Childs age 3. Childs sex 4. Childs donor status 5. Parents emotional state 6. Parent-child satisfaction 7. Disclosure status 8. Child behavioral adjustment 1 __ -.07 -.03 .02 -.02 -.18 -.08 -.02 2 3 4 __ .08 .03 -.01 .01 .21 .04 __ .01 -.04 -.01 .03 .04 __ -.00 -.01 .18 .08 5 6 7 __ -.32 __ .03 -.05 __ .34 -.53 .07 8 __ Conclusion Using our full sample, this studys findings replicate research showing that disclosure of ART conception has little effect on family relationships or child adjustment (Golombok et al., 2011; Lycett et al., 2004; Nachtigall et al., 1997). Our results depart from earlier research by revealing a subgroup of families whose experience differs from the majority. For families with a restricted communication context, disclosure negatively related to parent-child satisfaction, and through this relationship, related negatively to child behavioral adjustment. We interpret these findings not to mean that disclosure should be avoided in some families. Rather, we argue that parents who have strong reservations about discussing private information may benefit from therapeutic support. When disclosure of ART conception occurs in a restricted communication context , topic avoidance may bring to light an unwillingness to discuss the childs conception, leading to accumulating frustration that erodes relationship satisfaction (Petronio, 2002).Psychoeducational counseling can promote open communication, with the intention of creating a family context in which parents are open to and capable of handling conversations about childrens ART history.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • The Pendulum Effect - Project Management in Practice conference

    The Pendulum Effect - Project Management in Practice conference

    An alternative between those extremes is the Disciplined Agile Delivery framework developed by Scott Ambler. This approach is built around a standard Agile development process based on Scrum, but it recognizes the need to add a front-end to the Scrum...
  • Many Point Scout Camp - Boy Scout Troop 283

    Many Point Scout Camp - Boy Scout Troop 283

    Aqua Trampoline and Activity Island - Cool off by leaping into the lake from a 25 foot floating trampoline, or buy wooshing! into the lake. ... See & discuss effects of pollution on a sand village that you construct. ......
  • Hydrological Information System

    Hydrological Information System

    Hydrological Information System. Module - Automatic Weather Station and Automatic Rain Gauge. Anish ….. Hydro-Informatics Expert. The World Bank
  • Geopolitical Theories

    Geopolitical Theories

    State requires lebensraum Translates to "living space" Adolf Hitler used this theory to invade surrounding countries and build German nationalism Must devour other territories to achieve this goal HEARTLAND THEORY Founded by Sir Halford Mackinder World power is based on...
  • Dress Code - gocruisers.org

    Dress Code - gocruisers.org

    Dress Code Groveport Madison Board of Education Shorts and Skirts Shorts must end at or below mid thigh Skirts must end at or below mid thigh Shirts and Blouses Shirts and Blouses should NOT expose midriff or cleavage Undergarments must...
  • A Major Undertaking in Uralic Linguistics: the Uralic ...

    A Major Undertaking in Uralic Linguistics: the Uralic ...

    Ferenc HAVAS, Budapest Congressus Undecimus Internationalis Fenno-Ugristarum 12. 8. 2010 Piliscsaba * * An example to the last point: - there is no point, for instance, in making a query for possessive constructions, adpositions and numeral phrases simultaneously.


    Opening of parotid duct: It opens in the vestibule of the mouth opposite the upper second molar tooth. Surface anatomy: The duct is represented by the middle 1/3 of the line between a point on the lower border of tragus...
  • Innovative Telephone solutions - University of Nebraska-Lincoln

    Innovative Telephone solutions - University of Nebraska-Lincoln

    Small Office or Large Call Center. The tools that are utilized in large call centers to help with the high call volume can also be utilized to help with call flow in a small office environment.