RADICAL ENVIRONMENTALISM Emily Roberts Will Scheffler Myth Debunking/What

RADICAL ENVIRONMENTALISM Emily Roberts Will Scheffler  Myth Debunking/What

RADICAL ENVIRONMENTALISM Emily Roberts Will Scheffler Myth Debunking/What is Radical Environmentalism? Failure of Legislation Anna Schonleber Heidi Hirsh Effective Tactics

Case Study (Sea Shepherd: Reykjavik Raid) WHAT IT IS. HOW IT WORKS. EMILY ROBERTS EARTH LIFE FORCE 1977 ELF strives to inform and inspire the people about environmental issues This was the first eco-guerrilla unit to

use direct action and the name ELF. As originally conceived, the ELF would have no central leadership or chain of command. Each cell was intended to be autonomous and an individual could join or drop out at will. Anyone could call him or her self a member of ELF but no one can be an ELF leader. www.originalelf.org

EARTH FIRST! 1979 Our front-line, direct action approach to protecting wilderness gets results. We have succeeded in cases where other environmental groups had given up, and have drawn public attention to the crises facing the natural world. We believe in using all the tools in the tool box, ranging

from grassroots organizing and involvement in the legal process to civil disobedience and monkey wrenching. It is not an organization, but a movement. There are no "members" of Earth First!, only Earth First!ers. It is a belief in biocentrism, that life of the Earth comes first, and a practice of putting our beliefs into action. earthfirst.org/about.htm EARTH LIBERATION FRONT 1992

If, as stated, the ELF's mission is to defend and protect the Earth for future generations by means of direct action, then the high moral road must be taken in order to succeed. www.earth-liberation-front.org CLAIMS ABOUT RADICAL ENVIRONMENTALISM Claim: Radical environmentalism is

MYTH the same as eco-terrorism Eco-terrorism: the use or threatened use of violence of a criminal nature against people or property by an environmentally oriented, subnational group for environmental-political reasons, or aimed at an audience beyond the target, often of a symbolic nature As defined by the Federal Bureau of Investigation

Ecotage: sabotage with an ecological motive Oxford English Dictionary A dialogue with other activists led to a consensus that terrorist actions were clearly counter-productive to the environmental movement - regardless of the perceived righteousness of a given cause. The public will always reject violence and destructive actions.

www.originalelf.com Regardless of the frustration we all feel about the enormous perils facing our Mother Earth, engaging the perceived wrong-doers with threats, intimidation and destructive tactics will always fail. Fighting fire with fire will get you burned.

www.earth-liberation-front.org Claim: Radical environmentalism is MYTH violent and puts others in danger The tactics used by radical environmentalists are not meant to harm or kill people, but rather to stop actions that would negatively impact the environment

Monkey wrenching: to sabotage, disrupt, or damage as a form of environmentalist protest Ecotage: sabotage with an ecological motive Oxford English Dictionary John Hanna, original ELF founder, was convicted for using

explosives on federal property. He no longer advocates for the group but still says: ELF took extraordinary measures to avoid loss of life or injury. The devices were designed so only the low-yield detonators would fire. The napalm mix had been allowed to solidify so it could not catch fire. The fuses were set to ignite at 2:00am. I waited nearby until all the detonators exploded. If someone would have happened by, I was prepared to warn him or her off even at the risk of capture. www.originalelf.org

MYTH Claim: Radical environmentalists are misinformed about the issues and ultimate impacts of their actions Advice on the Earth First! website: Educate yourself on the ways you can attract attention to environmental concerns and dissuade people and corporations from destroying the Earth.

Learn the law. While getting arrested will often bring increased media attention, weigh all the options. Freedom is an important asset. Avoiding jail is sometimes a better strategy. Become aware of the risks to which you will be exposed. Activists are often arrested during legal actions by police ignorant of the law. CONCLUSION

The intent is not to harm others, and radical environmentalists take safety measures to try to decrease any possible dangers Radical environmentalism uses direct action that will draw public attention to an environmentally harmful action Their focus is on immediately stopping the action before the natural resource is lost due to the ineffectiveness of the slowness of legislation THE FAILURE OF

ENVIRONMENTAL LEGISLATION TABLE OF CONTENTS Environmental Legislations: - Outdated - Inherently Full Of Compromises - Full Of Loopholes, Short Sight, and Corruption - Take Too Long To Be Enacted LAWS ARE OUTDATED National Environmental Protection Act: 1970 Clean Air Act: 1970, Amended 1990

Clean Water Act: 1972 Ocean Dumping Act: 1972 Endangered Species Act: 1973 Safe Drinking Water Act: 1974 LAWS ARE INHERENTLY FULL OF COMPROMISE LOOPHOLES Loopholes in current laws: - RCRA allows scrap hazardous e-waste to be shipped to other nations Energy Policy Act of 2005 = Halliburton

Loophole SHORT SIGHT EPA failed to publicize information about common weed-killer in drinking water. CORRUPTION Breakup of MMS over Deepwater Horizon Blowout. LENGTH OF TIME IT TAKES TO

DRAW UP NEW REGULATIONS The adopting of environmental legislation and the enacting of regulations take extremely long just like any piece of government legislation, if not longer due to its highly controversial nature. WORKS CITED http://www.acslaw.org/acsblog/node/12601 http://www.newyorker.com/talk/financial/2010/06/14/1006 14ta_talk_surowiecki http://www.sierraclub.org/naturalgas/details.aspx

http://www.cleanwater.org/page/fracking-laws-and-loopho les TACTICS: THE BRIDGE BETWEEN WHAT DOESNT WORK AND WHAT DOES Anna Schonleber SEA SHEPHERD COMBATING OVER FISHING Operation Blue Rage 2011

Trying to lower the quota for Bluefin tuna Sea Shepherd holds the position that the quota should be set at zero Each Year Sea Shepherd sends out ships to search for illegal fishing operations

OPERATION BLUE RAGE 2011 We would be happy to remove ourselves from what should be the business of the ICCAT and the EU, if only they were actually doing the job. (SeaShepherd.org) JULIA BUTTERFLY HILL Goal: To prevent the clear cutting of of the giant redwood forest by Pacific Lumber Co.

Live 180ft in Luna a redwood tree Live on two 6ft by 6ft platforms for 738 days RESOLUTION Decision reached in 1999 Pacific Lumber Co. agreed to preserve Luna and all trees with in a 200ft buffer zone

Hill agreed to vacate Luna $50,000 was given to the logging company which was then donated to Humboldt State University to go toward research into sustainable forestry THE COVE Movie reveals massive dolphin slaughtering in Taiji, Japan Called attention to high mercury levels in dolphin meat

that was getting sold as part of a government sponsored school lunch program IWC (International Whaling Commission) Dolphins arent regulated by the IWC http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cSiQVdq9Pns CASE STUDY SEA SHEPHERDS REYKJAVIK RAID

HEIDI HIRSH http://www.cherrycoloured.com/wordpress/?p=10171 SEA SHEPHERD CONSERVATION SOCIETY We dont protest whaling we oppose illegal whaling activities. Our opposition are criminals engaged in illegal behavior. (seashepherd.org)

http://www.seashepherd.org FAILURE OF LAW 1986 International Whaling Commission moratorium on commercial whaling Purpose: Give the worlds dwindling population of whales a chance to recover.

Allow time to develop a satisfactory data base for determining a sustainable hunting quota for any future whaling. Icelandic government announced plans for a four-year study of whale populations. analysis would require killing several thousand fin, sei, and minke whales

Japan and Norway followed suit http://piperbayard.wordpress.com/2011/04/06/save-the-whales-eat-more-imperial-dwarf-deer/ TACTICS Mainstream environmental groups failed

Attempted to bring about the declaration of a boycott on Icelandic fish products American secretary of commerce, Malcolm Baldridge Two Sea Shepherds succeeded

Destroyed the refrigeration system at Whales Limited Dismantled diesel engines Demolished the laboratory

Poured acid on computer files Sank two ships of the fourvessel whaling fleet $4.8 million worth of damage REPERCUSSION Ecological Awakening S-

Two scuttled ships were raised but no longer seaworthy for further research Persuaded Icelanders to change their views on whaling Questioning of the formulation of environmental policy Rise of Icelands first activist

environmental group Hvalvinurfelag (Friends of the Whale) http://www.greenpeace.org/international/en/news/ features/iceland-whaling-makes-no-sense-030209/ Capt. Paul Watson flew to Iceland in 1988 and turned himself in to the authorities in accordance with the Sea Shepherd guideline of accepting moral and legal consequences for ones actions.

His presence was embarrassing for the Icelandic government He was held without charge for 24 hours then expelled without cause http://mediaboymusings.blogspot.com/2011/05/eco-pirate-story-of-paul-watson-film.html CASE STUDY REFERENCES Manes, Christopher. Green Rage: Radical Environmentalism and the

Unmaking of Civilization. Boston: Little, Brown, 1990. Watson, Paul. "The Big Green Do Nothing: Fundraising Machine Condemns Activism." Sea Shepherd. 10 Nov. 2011. Web. 2 Dec. 2011. http://www.seashepherd.org/ commentary-and-editorials/2011/11/10/the-big-green-do-nothingfundraising- machine-condemns-activism-492 Sahagun, Louis. "Whaling Clash Highlights Two Hollywood Donors." The Los Angeles Times.

LA Times, 07 Jan. 2010. Web. 06 Dec. 2011. . http://www.seashepherd.org REBUTTAL There is too much time between realizing that there is an environmental problem to getting legislation passed to fix the problem

It also takes time for the legislation to kick in and have any sort of effect on the problem Chart from a PBS article on the Clean Water Act

The chart continues to present times to show that there are still environmental problems that the act is not able to fix but that people may assume are covered by it. This creates the need for further action to draw public attention to the existing problem REBUTTAL Sea Shepherd believes they act under the World Charter for Nature of the United Nations which allows NGOs to

help enforce environmental laws (within the boundaries of law) when authorities fail to effectively do so. OBJECTIVE Radical environmentalism looks to bring media attention to bigger issues though tackling smaller issues themselves SEA SHEPHERD GUIDELINES Sea Shepherd crew members cannot use weapons. They cannot use explosives. They cannot undertake any action that could result in a

physical injury to humans. They must take responsibility for their actions. They must accept moral and legal consequences for their actions. INTERNATIONAL SUPPORT English schoolchildren raised $25,000 in a savethe-whale walkathon in Warner Brothers Sea

Shepherd II Hollywood Donors Ady Gil Bob Barker Animal Planet - Whale Wars

Hayden Panettiere VERSUS GREENPEACE The Accusation (from John Sauven, Executive Director of Greenpeace) we feel that we are winning the battle against whaling by talking to the Japanese themselves. Sea Shepherd are confronting Japanese people aggressively and it is exacerbating nationalism, and actually making it more difficult. Defense (Captain Paul Watson, founder and president of Sea Shepherd) Let me see JohnGreenpeace builds a 33 million Euro ship to conduct fundraising tours while we intervene directly against illegal Japanese whaling in the Southern Ocean. While you guys sent origami whales to President Obama to protest Japanese whaling, we

sent the Japanese fleet home with only 17% of their kill quota. Sea Shepherd has prevented the slaughter of nearly 3,000 whales while Greenpeacers were sitting and eating whale meat with the Japanese to demonstrate so-called sensitivity to Japanese culture. Greenpeace street solicitors tell the public that they send ships to the Southern Ocean, although they have not done so since 2006. They blatantly lie to raise funds. CRITICS The critics of Deep Ecology and radical environmentalism have been anything but restrained. Accused radical ecologists of being fascists and Marxists, terrorists and mystics, people with axes to grind and hucksters in pursuit of wine, women, and song,

destroyers of local economies, purveyors of distrust, obscurantists, atheists, misogynists and misanthropes. (Green Rage, p. 151) if any insult has been left out of the list, apologies are in order. Edward Abbey Radical environmentalism is best understood as an attempt to enlarge the circle of legal and ethical standing to include other species and even entire ecosystems. In this interpretation, radical environmentalism is anything

but revolutionary and extremist; it borders on patriotic. If conservation is defined ethically, it fits quite squarely into the most traditional of all American ideals: the defense of minority rights and the liberation of exploited groups. GOALS: Affect the public

Influence legislation Express personal moral opposition to environmental destruction PEACEFUL DIRECT ACTION CODE 1. Our attitude is one of openness, friendliness, and respect toward all beings we encounter. 2.

We will use no violence, verbal or physical, toward any being. 3. We will not damage any property and will discourage others from doing so. 4. We will not run. 5.

We will carry no weapons. Civil Disobedience: a form of bearing witness to injustice, a way of highlighting the violence of environmental exploitation by standing up peaceably in opposition to it. Direct action in the ecology movement is one way to generate tension, to expose myths and assumption of the dominant mindset, to create a situation in which corporations, developers and government agents are willing to negotiate. Bill Devall

Force industrial society to explain itself, to justify its actions. Bear witness to injustice Highlight environmental opposition by standing up peaceably in opposition to it. URGENCY Extreme urgency of the environmental crisis No second chance Once an old-growth forest is cut, it will not grow back for hundreds of years, if

ever. Once a species becomes extinct the battle is lost. The purpose of ecological civil disobedience is not to make farreaching changes in societys views of the environment, but merely to buy time for legal redress or for the emergence of public pressure.

Ex: Little Granite Creek Im happy to be here facing harassment by the FBI. I think Im here because Ive been effective in bring attention to the crisis on the planet. Dave Foreman

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Click icon to add picture AERO2705 Week 12

    Click icon to add picture AERO2705 Week 12

    Mr. Warwick Holmes. Executive Director Space Engineering. School of Aerospace, Mechanical and Mechatronic Engineering. AERO2705 Exam location. AERO2705 Exam location. AERO2705 Exam location. AERO2705EXAMFront Page(only!)6 more pages1 per question.
  • Definitive Landmark Study of Highly Important Condition: Another

    Definitive Landmark Study of Highly Important Condition: Another

    Definitive Landmark Study of Highly Important Condition: Another Outstanding Poster by Hopkins Experts Jane Q. Fellow, John Q. Technician, Jeanne T. Collaborator, James M. Senior-Author
  • Pension - eLearning Services - NIU - Northern Illinois University

    Pension - eLearning Services - NIU - Northern Illinois University

    Pension Benefits Administration. Service Purchase - Reciprocity - PENSION BENEFIT. Retirement . Prior Fund(s) 1/12 of 2.5% of final monthly salary for each month of service in that fund(s) Final Fund. Calculate benefit as if ALL service was with this...
  • MEN WITH A MISSION 1A Mens Discipleship Class

    MEN WITH A MISSION 1A Mens Discipleship Class

    It would be his family's need and Joseph would have to face his 'bitterness' and past. Why did God place Joseph in leadership over grain? Good question. But it proves Romans 8:28. What if Joseph had not been sent out...
  • Présentation PowerPoint

    Présentation PowerPoint

    Със стимулиращ компонент в такса сметосъбиране и сметоизвозване междуобщинските сдружения са намалили между 30 и 50% образуваните остатъчни битови отпадъци на глава от населението и са подобрили разделното си ...
  • 5:2732ppMt 9:913; Mk 2:14 17 27 After this,

    5:2732ppMt 9:913; Mk 2:14 17 27 After this,

    Matthew 9:9 (NIV) The Calling of Matthew . 9:9-13pp—Mk 2:14-17; Lk 5:27-32 . 9 As Jesus went on from there, he saw a man named Matthew sitting at the tax collector's booth. "Follow me," he told him, and Matthew got...
  • TP-CASTT (a way to Analyze Poetry)

    TP-CASTT (a way to Analyze Poetry)

    TPCASTT is a process to help you organize your analysis of poetry - any poem. You can also use the SIFT analysis, although TPCASTT is a bit more thorough for poetry. You could also use TPCASTT for a story/novel (with...
  • Social Entrepreneurship

    Social Entrepreneurship

    Founded by English celebrity chef Jamie Oliver in 2002, Fifteen started out as an ambitious effort to offer disadvantaged youths (aged 18-24) a means of creating better futures for themselves through the art of good food. The restaurant initiative was...