An evaluation of thermostatic mixer valves to reduce

An evaluation of thermostatic mixer valves to reduce

An evaluation of thermostatic mixer valves to reduce bath water temperature in homes of families with young children living in social housing Denise Kendrick Professor of Primary Care Research University of Nottingham Jane Stewart Senior Research Fellow Nottinghamshire Healthcare Trust (NHS Nottinghamshire County) And co- authors The problem bath hot tap water scalds in young children Each year 2,000 ED attendances, 500 admissions Most admissions children < 5years Steep social gradient most deprived most vulnerable Domestic hot water temperatures can scald in about a second

Cost of severe scald ~ 250 000 What is a Thermostatic Mixer Valve (TMV)? Engineering solution to reduce the temperature of hot bath tap water temperature No active participation by parents required Mixes hot and cold bath tap water to pre-set temperature - 46 C Takes 6 hours for a scald at this temperature Aims of the study To assess TMVs for their: Effectiveness and cost effectiveness in reducing bath hot water temperature Acceptability to families Impact on bath time safety practices In families with children under the age of 5 years living in social housing Methods Randomised controlled trial Questionnaire at baseline

Delivered the intervention TMV Educational leaflet Laminated leaflet on how to use TMV Water temperature checks at baseline, 3 and 12 months Questionnaire at 12 months follow up Fieldwork in Glasgow Participants 124 families completed baseline questionnaire Intervention arm 62 (46 TMVs fitted) Control arm 62 Water temps: baseline n=23 3 months n=15 12 months n=16

Water temps: baseline n=27 3 months n=15 12 months n=15 12 month questionnaire 44 still tenants/participating 12 month questionnaire 49 still tenants/participating 40 returned (91.9%) 40 returned (81.6%) Characteristics of participants Characteristics Intervention arm n=62 Control arm n=62

Mother completed questionnaire 57 (91.9) 58 (93.6) Single adult household 40 (64.5) 47 (75.8) Number of children in the home 1 2 29 (46.8) 21 (33.9) 25 (40.3) 26 (41.9) 38 (73.1) [10] 43 (72.9) [3]

Number of adults in paid employment 0 1 39 (65.0) [2] 16 (26.7) 40 (65.6) [1] 17 (27.9) Family receives state benefits 50 (82.0) [1] 56 (90.3) Ethnic group of respondent White Scottish Black African 54 (88.5) [1] 6 (9.8)

54 (88.5) [1] 3 (4.9) Age respondent left full time education 16 [ ] missing values Acceptability of bath hot tap water (baseline) Intervention arm Satisfaction (number (%)) Very happy or happy with bath hot tap water temperature Bath water is: Very hot need to add a lot of cold water to the bath Hot need to add some cold water to the bath [ ] missing values Control arm

n=62 n=62 39 (62.9) 37 (59.7) 41 (67.2) [1] 38 (61.3) 19 (31.2) 24 (38.7) Bath time safety practices (baseline) Safety practices Runs bath using cold water first Intervention arm n=62

Control arm N=62 2 (3.2) 9 (14.8) [1] 54 (88.5) [1] 54 (88.5) [1] Child has been left alone in the bath 27 (43.6) 13 (21.0) Child has been left alone in bathroom whilst bath is running 19 (30.7) 12 (19.4)

Bath water temperature checked for every bath [ ] missing values 40 12 month water temperature (degrees Celsius) 50 60 70 80 90 100 40 40 3 month water temperature (degrees Celsius) 50 60 70 80

90 100 Baseline water temperature (degrees Celsius) 50 60 70 80 90 100 Hot bath tap water temperatures at baseline, 3 and 12 months Control arm Intervention arm Control arm Control arm Intervention arm Intervention arm

Were parents satisfied with the TMV? Intervention arm responders with TMV fitted (n=34) Very happy or happy with TMV 30 (88.2) Would recommend TMV to a friend 28 (87.5) [2] Would not be happy if kitchen and bath hot tap water were same temperature 23 (69.7) [1] Since having TMV Child less likely to be scalded 32 (94.1) Doesnt take longer to run bath 22 (68.8) [2]

Easier to control bath water temperature 29 (90.6) [2] Bath water isnt hot enough 12 (36.4) [1] Can no longer top up bath with hot water whilst in the bath 9 (27.3) [1] Acceptability of bath hot tap water (follow up) Intervention arm Responders n=40 (%) Very happy or happy with bath hot tap water temperature

Bath water is: Very hot need to add a lot of cold water to the bath Hot need to add some cold water to the bath Warm enough - dont need to add any cold water to the bath 32 (82.1) [1] 7 (18.0) [1] 16 (41.0) 14 (35.9) Control arm Responders n=40 (%) 23 (57.5) Relative Risk (95% CI)

1.43 (1.05, 1.93) 22 (55.0) 18 (45.0) 0 (0.0) 0.33 (0.16, 0.68) Bath time safety practices (follow up) Runs bath using cold water first* Bath water temperature checked for every bath Child has been left alone in the bath* Child has been left alone in bathroom whilst bath is running* Intervention arm responders n=40(%)

Control arm responde rs n=40(%) Relative Risk (95% CI) 5 (12.5) 11 (27.5) 0.55 (0.22, 1.39) 32 (84.2) [2] 40 (100.0) 0.84 (0.73, 0.97) 13 (32.5) 8 (20.5) [1]

1.11 (0.51, 2.41) 12 (30.8) [1] 9 (22.5) 1.28 (0.62, 2.68) Health economic analysis Professor Ceri Phillips - Swansea University NHS costs to treat a scald range from 25, 226 - 71, 902 Cost-effectiveness analysis indicated a potential saving to the NHS of 3, 229, 008 1.41 saved for every 1 spent Summary TMVs are effective in reducing bath hot tap water temperature Majority of parents satisfied with the TMV and the temperature Would recommend a TMV to a friend Feel child less likely to be scalded

However, parents checking temperature of bath water less often A third of people reported bath water not hot enough Implications Suggests that parents are willing to trade some inconvenience for increased safety TMVs should be considered as a scald prevention intervention for families with children Important to reinforce bath time safety messages about checking the water temperature and leaving children alone in the bath Cost effective solution requires interagency working spend money in one sector to save money in another Funding Policy Research Programme (PRP) at the Department of Health -Accidental Injury Prevention Research Initiative (001/0009)

The final study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation of results, and paper writing was the sole responsibility of the authors. The views and opinions expressed in this paper do not necessarily reflect those of the funding body. This is an independent report commissioned and funded by the Policy Research Program in the Department of Health. The views expressed are not necessarily those of the Department. Thank you for listening! Any questions?

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Tragedy and Comedy

    Tragedy and Comedy

    Arial Lucida Sans Book Antiqua Wingdings 2 Wingdings Wingdings 3 Calibri Tahoma Apex 1_Apex intro to drama Fundamental Differences Between Ancient and Modern Life Organization of Society Rights and Responsibilities of Individuals Material Well-Being Spiritual and Psychological Well-Being Chief Irony...
  • Issue Y2K The Great War for Talent!

    Issue Y2K The Great War for Talent!

    Tom Peters' Re-Imagine! Business Excellence in a Disruptive Age REI.500/19May2005
  • The Northern Kingdom (Israel)  7 prophets The Southern

    The Northern Kingdom (Israel) 7 prophets The Southern

    The prophet Elijah. Elijah, confronting Ahab, said: "As the LORD, the God of Israel, lives, whom I serve, there will be neither dew nor rain in the next few years except at my word." 1 Kings 17:1. p. 203, The...
  • CE 595 Section 1 - Purdue Engineering

    CE 595 Section 1 - Purdue Engineering

    In general, Section 1.3 : Energy Methods Energy methods are techniques for satisfying equilibrium or compatibility on a global level rather than pointwise. Two general types can be identified: Methods that assume equilibrium and enforce displacement compatibility. (Virtual force principle,...
  • Taxation Des Interets De Comptes a L&#x27;Etranger Et Amnistie ...

    Taxation Des Interets De Comptes a L'Etranger Et Amnistie ...

    PARTAGE DE L'AVOIR SOCIAL OPERATIONS DE FUSION OU DE SCISSION FISCALEMENT NEUTRE ne sont, en aucun cas, soumises à la taxation : les plus-values antérieurement exonérées exprimées mais non réalisées ("plus-values de réévaluation"); les plus-values réalisées (encore) à taxer de...
  • Introduction to Linguistics - Arif Awaludin&#x27;s Notes | Catatan ...

    Introduction to Linguistics - Arif Awaludin's Notes | Catatan ...

    langue, the language system of a speech community. langue. denotes a system of internalised, shared rules governing a national language's vocabulary, grammar, and sound system; Parole. designates actual oral and written communication by a member or members of a particular...
  • Florida Assessments for Instruction in Reading aligned to

    Florida Assessments for Instruction in Reading aligned to

    This is the Florida Department of Education (FLDOE) Single Sign On (SSO) Home Page. FAIR-FS Train-the-Trainer July 2014. ... "On the FLDOE SSO Sign In page, the User will: Enter his or her User Name. Enter his or her Password....
  • Racial and Ethnic Relations Chapter 9: Racial and

    Racial and Ethnic Relations Chapter 9: Racial and

    Reading Check 2.9 Million Individuals Original inhabitants of the United States Disease, warfare, and destruction of traditional ways of life reduced numbers dramatically U.S. government took traditional lands and forced Native Americans onto reservations Policies encouraged assimilation into white culture...