Update on the IRC Section 41 Research Tax

Update on the IRC Section 41 Research Tax

Update on the IRC Section 41 Research Tax Credit Michael A. Krajcer, JD, CPA Office: (440) 331-0714 Mobile: (216) 308-1564 1 Overview Interpretation The Courts Regulation IRS/Treasury Legislation Congress/President

2 Interpretation FedEx v. United States TG Missouri Corporation v. Commissioner Trinity Industries Inc. v. United States Deere v. commissioner

Procter & Gamble v. United States 3 Interpretation (cont.) FedEx v. United States, 103 A.F.T.R. 2d 2009-2722 (W.D. Tenn. 6/9/09) Taxpayer developing Internal Use Software, wants to rely on the qualification tests found in the 2001 final regulations, but modified to recognize the elimination of the Discovery Test pursuant to the 2003 final regulations. IRS argued that its Announcement 2004-9 precluded the taxpayer from doing so. Holding: For the taxpayer

Announcement 2004-9 is not due substantial deference since it is contrary to the IRS stated intent in adopting the 2003 regulations and contrary to the IRS stated understanding of Congressional intent 4 Interpretation (cont.) TG Missouri Corporation v. Commissioner, 133 T.C. 278 (Nov. 12, 2009) Taxpayer contracted for production molds it would use to make automotive parts for its customers. The molds were held as inventory until complete, then sold to the related customer. The IRS argued that the cost of the molds could not qualify as supply QREs, since they were property of a character subject to depreciation.

Holding: The court held for the taxpayer, stating that the particular taxpayer and such taxpayers use of the property must be referenced when determining if the property is in fact property of a character subject to depreciation. 5 Interpretation (cont.) Trinity Industries Inc. v. United States, 691 F. Supp.2d 688 (Jan. 29, 2010) Issues: Business Component Test made-to-order prototypes Substantially All Test Holding: For the taxpayer Research conducted for a particular customer will qualify for the research credit

Where the taxpayer provided sufficient evidence that substantially all (i.e. 80%) of a projects activities qualified, then all the costs of the project were allowed in calculating the credit. Note: Had the taxpayer retained documentation to verify that something less than substantially all of a project qualified, the court would have followed the shrinking back theory to allow the qualified portion of the project. 6 Interpretation (cont.) Deere v. Commissioner, 133 T.C. 246 (Oct. 22, 2009) Taxpayer argued that the gross receipts of foreign branches should be excluded from the calculation of the credit, similar to

the exclusion specifically granted to foreign corporation gross receipts that are not effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or business within the United States. Holding: Noting that the "silence of Congress is strident," the Tax Court found that if Congress had wanted to exclude income from foreign branches from gross receipts, it would have done so explicitly. 7 Interpretation (cont.) Procter & Gamble v. United States, 733 F. Supp. 2d 877 (June 25, 2010) The taxpayer excluded receipts from intercompany transactions, including foreign subsidiary amounts, for purposes of calculating

Gross Receipts. The IRS argued that for foreign subsidiaries, IRC Section 41(f) applies only to research expenditures, not gross receipts. Holding: For the taxpayer: The district court rejected the IRS's argument concluding that for a controlled group of corporations, both QREs and Gross Receipts should be determined on a single-taxpayer basis. 8 Regulation IRS/Treasury Department issue final regulations regarding election of the Alternative Simplified Credit Taxpayers cannot make or revoke an election for the ASC

after they file their original tax returns. No Section 9100 relief is available. TD 9528; 76 FR 33994 Effective June 9, 2011 9 Legislation Administration Proposal: Permanent Credit Increase ASC rate from 14% to 17% Congressional Bills: S. 1577: Greater Research Opportunities with Tax Help Act of 2011 (GROWTH Act) Permanent Credit

Increase ASC rate from 14% to 20% H.R. 1693: Research and Development Tax Credit Extension Act of 2011 Permanent Credit Increase ASC rate from 14% to 17% 10 Speaker Biography Michael A. Krajcer, JD, CPA Over 25 years experience in tax consulting and tax controversy resolution B.B.A in Accounting, Kent State University

J.D., Cleveland Marshall College of Law 13 years with the IRS Previous leader of Ernst &Youngs IRS Practice and Procedure Group in Cleveland and member of E & Ys National Tax Practice, and VP at National City Bank Adjunct professor, Cleveland Marshall College of Law 11

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Marking and Feedback - Let there be marks

    Marking and Feedback - Let there be marks

    Enhance chemistry students' numeric skills. Boost students' confidence tackling challenging mathematical problems. Generate practice questions and feedback that support learning cycles
  • Shinkin International Ltd.

    Shinkin International Ltd.

    Shinkin International. Shinkin International Ltd. has been successfully arranging MTNs for Japanese wholesale investors since 1996. Until 2006 our business was dominated by structured trades - often bermudan callable - but in recent years higher spreads on vanilla credit has...
  • Project Scheduling - The College of Business

    Project Scheduling - The College of Business

    Construct the network. Activity Predecessors A -- B A C A D B E B F C G D H E, F Network Example - AON A C E F B D G H Z Network Example - AOA 2...
  • THANK YOU Thank you for your purchase. You

    THANK YOU Thank you for your purchase. You

    Two words that have similar sounds at the end rhyme, such as "cat" and "hat" are an example of words that rhyme. Children develop the ability to hear rhyming words over time by singing songs, and listening to nursery rhymes...
  • スライド 0 - cosmos.eri.ucsb.edu

    スライド 0 - cosmos.eri.ucsb.edu

    WataruSuzuki , Takashi Kunugi, Shin Aoi (National Research Institute for Earth Science and Disaster Prevention, Japan) COSMOS Strong Motion Forum at the 15WCEE, 25 September, 2012. K-NET and KiK-net observation stations.
  • The new X++ Language - Meetup

    The new X++ Language - Meetup

    The new X++ language. The X++ language remains the vehicle for developing application code for Dynamics AX7. We have made changes to achieve: Better consistency with other managed languages. Better integration with the managed stack (CIL). Some cleanup - Fewer...
  • ECO290E: Game Theory

    ECO290E: Game Theory

    ECO290E: Game Theory ... profile s* is a Bayesian NE if which is equivalent to Calculation Maximizing RHS is identical to maximizing inside the brackets for all possible i's type. … 0 0 2π deviation … π π π collusion...
  • TONE - Gillian Duff's English Resources

    TONE - Gillian Duff's English Resources

    TONE What it is and how to recognise it … What is tone? The writer's or speaker's attitude toward the subject & the audience. With speaking, tone is easy to hear in a person's voice. With writing, tone is determined...