School Of Health And Related Research Online surveys

School Of Health And Related Research Online surveys

School Of
Health
And
Related
Research

Online surveys of societal preferences do we know what respondents are
doing?
A literature review
Donna Rowen, Mandy Ryan, Aki Tsuchiya, Verity Watson, Universities of Sheffield and Aberdeen

Background

The question

Search and hits

Societal perspective?

The papers reviewed
Desser, A.S., Gyrd-Hansen, D., Olsen, J.A.,
Grepperud, S., Kristiansen, I.S., 2010.
Societal views on orphan drugs: cross
sectional survey of Norwegians aged 40 to
67. BMJ 341, c4715.

Key word Search
-social values
-resource allocation
-on-line survey
-health

Eisenberg, D., Freed, G.L., Davis, M.M.,
Singer, D., Prosser, L.A., 2011. Valuing health
at different ages: evidence from a nationally
representative survey in the US. Applied
Health Economics & Health Policy 9, 149-156.

Database: Medline 1946
onwards in English

Lim, M.K., Bae, E.Y., Choi, S.E., Lee, E.K., Lee,
T.J., 2012. Eliciting public preference for
health-care resource allocation in South
Korea. Value in Health 15, Suppl-4.

Hits: 207
Included: Societal values in
health using online survey: 13
papers, covering 14 studies

Linley, W.G., Hughes, D.A., 2013. Societal
views on NICE, cancer drugs fund and valuebased pricing criteria for prioritising
medicines: a cross-sectional survey of 4118
adults in Great Britain. Health Economics 22,
948-964.

Year of publication: 20022013, and 9 of the 13 published
2010 or later

Norman, R., Hall, J., Street, D., Viney, R.,
2013. Efficiency and equity: a stated
preference approach. Health Economics 22,
568-581.

Journals: 9 different journals
including British Medical Journal
[2]; Health Economics [3]; and
Value in Health [2]

Richardson, J., Sinha, K., Iezzi, A., Maxwell,
A., 2012. Maximising health versus sharing:
measuring preferences for the allocation of
the health budget. Social Science & Medicine
75, 1351-1361.
Schwappach, D.L., 2002. The equivalence of
numbers: the social value of avoiding health
decline: an experimental Web-based study.
BMC Medical Informatics & Decision Making
2, 3.

Countries: Australia [2];
Europe [8]; US; other
Topics covered: patient age,
baseline health (QOL, survival),
health gain (QOL, survival),
unmet need, end of life,
dependents, sex, ethnicity,
income, smoking
(responsibility), rarity

Ex post perspective?

Schwappach, D.L., 2003. Does it matter who
you are or what you gain? An experimental
study of preferences for resource allocation.
Health Economics 12, 255-267.
Schwappach, D.L., 2005. Are preferences for
equality a matter of perspective? Medical
Decision Making 25, 449-459.
Schwappach, D.L., Strasmann, T.J., 2006.
"Quick and dirty numbers"? The reliability of
a stated-preference technique for the
measurement of preferences for resource
allocation. Journal of Health Economics 25,
432-448.

Recruitment: self selected
open access [1]; convenience
sample [2]; online panel [10]
Sample size: 127-4118;
median 800; mean 1198
Method: DCE [5]; PTO/budget
pie [6]; other

Ex ante

Ex post

Clearly societal

0

7

Potentially personal

0

5

Conclusion

Singh, J., Lord, J., Longworth, L., Orr, S.,
McGarry, T., Sheldon, R., Buxton, M., 2012.
Does responsibility affect the public's
valuation of health care interventions? A
relative valuation approach to health care
safety. Value in Health 15, 690-698.
van der Wulp I. van den Hout WB. de Vries
M. Stiggelbout AM. van den Akker-van Marle
EM., 2012. Societal preferences for standard
health insurance coverage in the
Netherlands: a cross-sectional study. BMJ
Open 2, e001021.

Acknowledgements

Werntoft, E., Edberg, A.K., 2009. The views of
physicians and politicians concerning ageThis poster was prepared for
related prioritisation in healthcare. Journal of
Health
& Management
38HESGOrganization
/ GCU June
2014, 23,
with
52.

thanks to Anna Cantrell for
conducting the literature
search.

Contact us
Corresponding author: Donna Rowen

www.sheffield.ac.uk/heds;
@HERU_Abdn

@sharrheds;

www.abdn.ac.uk/heru;

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • C++

    C++

    Introduzione al C++ e alla programmazione ad oggetti Corso Specialistico CNTC Bologna, 19-23 febbraio 2001 Andrea Dell'Acqua e Claudio Grandi Introduzione Le due componenti principali dei programmi: Algoritmi: l'insieme delle istruzioni che svolgono un particolare compito Dati: ciò su cui...
  • Hobbs Williams December Parent Newsletter Elementary What Were

    Hobbs Williams December Parent Newsletter Elementary What Were

    Explore and describe water as streams, ponds, rivers, lakes, and geysers; Identify natural resources by exploring rocks, soil, and water used in patterns Social Studies: Holiday Traditions
  • Springboard Activity 1.11 - campbell.k12.ky.us

    Springboard Activity 1.11 - campbell.k12.ky.us

    Developing Vocabulary: QHT Chart with the academic and literary vocab words. Q. H. T. Embedded Assessment #2. Creating an Illustrated Myth. Make a web including what you will need to know and add to make your myth complete. Turn to...
  • The Publication of the Rotary Club of Arlington

    The Publication of the Rotary Club of Arlington

    You can make up meetings by: attending another clubs weekly meeting, doing a online eclub meeting on the RI website, donating Blood, doing meals on wheels, volunteering for any Rotary sponsored community service project or attending any other Rotary event...
  • Classroom Management - birdvilleschools.net

    Classroom Management - birdvilleschools.net

    "A classroom management plan sets the purpose to the classroom. The plan will help you create a culture of success, consistency, and academic excellence." --Harry K. WongThe Classroom Management Book p. 24. Quote from p. 5 from Jacob Kounin with...
  • Renal Bladder Ultrasound - Inland Imaging

    Renal Bladder Ultrasound - Inland Imaging

    Renal Bladder Ultrasound Protocol Example "One longitudinal view of each kidney with sufficient volume of liver or spleen to allow comparison of the relative echogenicity of those organs to the kidneys…" For example… One transverse cine of the left kidney...
  • Myths, folktales, and archetypes - Highlands High School

    Myths, folktales, and archetypes - Highlands High School

    Myths, folktales, and archetypes. Understanding how culture shapes our values. ... Folktales feature magic and gods and goddesses but they are not the central figures in the story. ... 6 types of characterization. By the views of other characters.
  • Chapter 59

    Chapter 59

    Truss: For people not able to undergo surgery and is mainly for males. It is a pad made with firm material and is held inplace over the hernia with a belt to keep the abdominal contents from protruding into the...