Introduction to Legal Issues on Social Media & the Federal ...

Introduction to Legal Issues on Social Media & the Federal ...

Introduction to Legal Issues on Social Media & the Federal Government Peter Swire Ohio State University Center for American Progress DHS Conference June 23, 2009 Overview

Overview of legal issues Legal and policy issues in procuring 2.0 services Six Legal Hurdles 1. Privacy 1. Persistent cookies 2. Data that goes to 3rd party sites

2. Access for people with disabilities 1. Section 508 2. When does it apply to 3rd party sites 3. Commercial endorsement & advertising Six Legal Hurdles 4. Terms of service 1. State law & indemnity clauses, etc.

5. Paperwork Reduction Act 1. Surveys on the web 2. How to do analytics 6. Computer security & use of 2.0 by federal employees 1. Platforms & their aps

This Panel

Procurement Peter Swire Terms of Service Jodi Cramer Ethics (endorsement) Bob Coyle Records Management Laurence Brewer Privacy Act Kirsten Moncada E-Gov/FOIA/PRA/cookies/FACA Alex Tang First Amendment Aden Fine Procurement Overview of Buying

Free 2.0 Software 3 phases of federal procurement 3 options for procurement Use procurement for free 2.0 services Enable open use of 2.0 Enable conditional use of 2.0 Some recommendations

3 Phases of Software Procurement Custom software NASA rocket software & no private-sector producers Government contracts for custom software Commercial off the shelf software DoD shouldnt write its own word processing software

COTS & GSA schedules 3 Phases of Procurement 2.0 Free Services Procurement law (FAR) applies to the acquiring by contract with appropriated funds Possibly is a concession such as restaurant at national park; but, concessions involve payment of money to the government

Therefore, likely not a procurement under the FAR or DFAR when agency signs up for 2.0 free services Use Procurement Anyways? Pro: Well defined & fair procedures Multiple vendors can alert government to their services

Reduce risk of (perceived) favoritism Avoid lock-in & get to best service at lowest total cost of ownership Use Procurement Anyways? (2) Con: Full procurement will slow use of Web 2.0, especially for smaller sites/agencies/uses Not clear have authority to do procurement when

outside of required scope of the FAR Administrative burden of approving contracts This sort of formal procurement for 2.0 rarely used in the private sector, so why is it worth it for government agencies? Option 2: Open Use of 2.0 Idea government can use 2.0 the way private organizations do

Pro: Encourage rapid adoption of 2.0, consistent with Obama administration statements Encourage experimentation Fewer dollars than paying for software Favoritism concerns are limited by no direct flow of dollars to the vendors Option 2 Open Use of 2.0

Con: Still risk of favoritism and lock-in, especially for high-visibility sites such as Open use does not push for government policies for privacy, security, Section 508, FOIA, and other issues Option 3: Conditional Use of 2.0 Actually have a sliding scale from formal

procurement to open use of 2.0 Procedural conditions Get approvals (GC, management) before 2.0 Use 2.0 to govern 2.0, with comments section about vendors, alternative technologies, etc. Option 3: Conditional Use Substantive conditions Instead of requiring full compliance with privacy,

508, etc., can require consideration of such issues, perhaps combined with procedural safeguards A major strategic question how hard to insist on complete compliance with every substantive rule, for 3rd party services, during the ramp-up phase we are in Recommendations

My paper supports conditional use that is fairly close to open use Policy statement encouraging 2.0 & transparency as a model Public comment feature so feedback on vendors & features Conditional use & consider privacy, 508, etc. in choosing 2.0 services Be open to statutory & regulatory changes to move

government & private services toward better achievement of multiple goals over time

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Year group's year ahead meeting

    Year group's year ahead meeting

    Boudicca was a queen of the British Celtic Iceni tribe who led an uprising against the occupying forces of the Roman Empire. invade. Enter a place or land with the intention of occupying it. Rome was created by two brothers,...
  • Sing Up - Music Mark

    Sing Up - Music Mark

    Sing Up's history. A report by Kathryn Deane, Rob Hunter and Phil Mullen March 2011 . Sing Up Beyond the Mainstream (SUBTM) in the eyes of many internal and external stakeholders in the community music sector seemed to have 'worked'....
  • Scout Sniper Team Leaders Course

    Scout Sniper Team Leaders Course

    SCOUT SNIPER TEAM LEADERS COURSE. Purpose: To train students in the advanced skills associated with the billet of team leader within a Scout Sniper Platoon.
  • Statewide Planning Public Participation Plan Public Participation Advisory

    Statewide Planning Public Participation Plan Public Participation Advisory

    Why we need a Plan. Public engagement is integral to good transportation planning. Meaningful public participation helps improve the decision making process and provides lasting contributions to Rhode Island's quality of life.
  • LITERARY ANALYSIS The Millers Tale and The Pardoners

    LITERARY ANALYSIS The Millers Tale and The Pardoners

    To begin, the narrators, the Miller and the Pardoner, share a similar satirical tone, which adds humor and pokes fun at the characters for their flaws. Example Concluding Sentence (last sentence in body paragraph) To repeat, these two tales both...
  • Chemistry Lab Drawer Equipment -

    Chemistry Lab Drawer Equipment -

    Common Science Laboratory Equipment The End Put it all together With one partner, sort out the paper cut outs of lab equipment in the envelope provided Place the appropriate name and definition with the correct picture Ask if you have...
  • Cross-Border Reach of US Securities Regulation

    Cross-Border Reach of US Securities Regulation

    Cross-Border Reach of US Securities Regulation US firms selling abroad Foreign firms selling in US Foreign securities transactions in US courts Last updated 05 Mar 12 Flowback Hypo #1 (flowback) Electro Motors Corp. (a California corporation) is a start-up company...
  • The CP vs. MOF problem What was originally

    The CP vs. MOF problem What was originally

    A task group chaired by IUPAC Polymer division's Richard Jones is currently revising the IUPAC recommendations from 1984 for the nomenclature of Coordination and Inorganic Polymers. Comment. The use of an IUPAC endorsed name in a flowing text will be...