General Damages Measures in Contract Situations

General Damages Measures in Contract Situations

Wrongful Death Lawsuits oBrought by survivors of the decedent on their own behalf seeking damages representing survivors losses as a result of decedents death oHeavily regulated by statute e.g., Mo. Rev. Stat. 537.080 & 537.090 oWhat kinds of losses can a wrongful death P recover? oOriginal rule pecuniary/economic losses only o Medical/funeral expenses, loss of support (what decedent earned less what she would have spent on herself) oMost states now allow at least recovery of pecuniary losses & loss of services o Loss of services = training, nurture, education, counsel, housework, etc.

Additional possible recoveries for wrongful death depending on the state: Loss of society a slight majority of states also allow Loss of society = loss of companionship, comfort, attention, love Note Missouri (like many states) loss of positive attributes only How should we measure loss of society? More additional possible recoveries for wrongful death depending on the state: Loss of inheritance some states allow recovery here

too Loss of inheritance = the amount of $ P can show decedents estate would have accumulated over and above the value of financial support P must prove more than a mere expectancy of inheriting Must show probably would have inherited from decedent and evidence from which amount of inheritance can be calculated What kind of evidence? Hedonic & Punitive Damages w/ Wrongful Death Hedonic damages o

Damages allowing survivor to recover for value of decedents loss of life i.e., recovery for intrinsic value of decedents life itself o General rule: Not available in wrongful death actions o Compare recovery of hedonic (aka loss of enjoyment of life) damages in personal injury context Punitive Damages o Jurisdictions split as to whether punitive damages are available in wrongful death actions

o Missouri judges have read the statute to allow punitive damages The Tort Reform Movement additional issues in limiting rightful position Earlier we saw that damages that could be (relatively) easily measured could also be limited: Liquidated damages/limited remedies clauses, judicial doctrines of offset and avoidable consequences Even so, could still conceive of Ps position after implementation of these doctrines as Ps rightful position With personal injury and wrongful death damages, limitations on

damages usually are statutory (although offset/avoidable consequences can apply here too) To what extent do these statutes raise problems? What pushes legislatures to enact these limits? Arbino the statute & the arguments Ohio law limited all non-economic (pain & suffering) damages to the greater of $250,000 or 3X the economic damages up to a maximum of $350,000 per person or $500,000 per occurrence Economic damages were not limited Limits on non-economic damages did not apply to severe injuries Why would states limit awards of non-economic damages? Did the limits raise problems constitutional or otherwise as the

plaintiff argued in Arbino? If you believe the limits are okay, is there a point at which the caps would be too low i.e., if the non-economic damage caps were set at $25,000 or $100 and there was no exception for severe injuries? Or if ALL damages were capped? Missouri Medical Malpractice Statute Mo. Rev. Stat. 538.210 1. In any action against a health care provider for damages for personal injury or death arising out of the rendering of or the failure to render health care services, no plaintiff shall recover more than [$350,000] dollars for noneconomic damages irrespective of the number of defendants. 3. In any action against a health care provider for damages for personal injury or death arising out of the rendering of or the failure to render

health care services, where the trier of fact is a jury, such jury shall not be instructed by the court with respect to the limitation on an award of noneconomic damages, nor shall counsel for any party or any person providing testimony during such proceeding in any way inform the jury or potential jurors of such limitation. Fate of Sec. 538.210 Missouri SCT found Sec. 538.210 to be an unconstitutional infringement of the right to a jury trial under Missouri Constitution Watts v. Cox Medical Ctrs., 376 SW3d 633 (2012) Mo Const. Art. I, Sec. 22(a) Right to a jury trial as hereby enjoyed shall be inviolate. MO SCT interprets this as meaning the right to a jury as it was understood when the MO Constitution was adopted in 1820

Tort Reform Proposals & Remedies Most common proposals for tort reform take the form of those listed at pp. 128-29 n.1. Most of these proposals are remedial in nature. Why limit remedies as opposed to other aspects of the legal system that are problematic? Who is likely to bear the result of those costsavings the most? Tort Reform, Statutory Limits & the Collateral Source Rule Common law rule that holds: P may recover damages that include amounts for which P has already received compensation from sources independent of and collateral to the defendant. Limits on collateral source rule have been a prime target of tort reform battles. See NY statutes mandatory offset for collateral source payments in personal

injury, property injury or wrongful death cases (Oden) Reasoning for such statutory limits: Ps shouldnt be allowed to recover twice for their injury allowing damages & collateral sources is double recovery Judges dont often find such limits unconstitutional (unlike the situations in Arbino). But they can read statutory limits on collateral source pretty narrowly. Note how the Oden court parses NY statute to see which of the benefits sources is or is not an offsetting collateral source Damages for Dignitary Torts What is a dignitary tort? Torts that assault or impair our dignity but dont necessarily cause physical or pecuniary harm. Examples: Assault, Defamation, False Imprisonment, IIED, NIED,

Malicious prosecution, Invasion of privacy As with pain & suffering damages, difficult valuation issues arise Levka v. City of Chicago P sued for emotional distress resulting from illegal search after misdemeanor arrest. Awarded $50,000 for emotional distress but 7th Circuit remits to $25,000. What could Levkas attorney have done differently to convince the appellate court of her emotional distress? Focus on plaintiffs harm

Emphasize particular frailty Reframe inferences court drew from evidence Bolster psychological evidence Focus on defendants conduct Try to frame it as more outrageous than court characterized it

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Python Lesson 12 - Mr. Kalmes Classroom Website

    Python Lesson 12 - Mr. Kalmes Classroom Website

    Python Lesson 12. Mr. Kalmes. Aims. ... first, second, and third. This may look strange, but "unpack" is probably the best word to describe what it does. It just says, "Take whatever is in argv, unpack it, and assign it...
  • Population Regulation -

    Population Regulation -

    Outline Intro to Population Ecology Estimating Patterns of Survival Survivorship Curves Age Distribution Rates of Population Change Overlapping Generations
  • PAST AICE EXAMS PAST AICE EXAMS PAST AICE EXAMS. June 2015. In many Asian societies, there has been an increase in female headed households.This is due to a variety of reasons including widowhood, migration, marital instability and women choosing to have children outside of marriage.
  • Lecture 2 Rule-based expert systems  Introduction, or what

    Lecture 2 Rule-based expert systems Introduction, or what

    Forward chaining is a technique for gathering information and then inferring from it whatever can be inferred. However, in forward chaining, many rules may be executed that have nothing to do with the established goal. Therefore, if our goal is...
  • Basic Concepts of Strategic Management Chapter 1 Learning

    Basic Concepts of Strategic Management Chapter 1 Learning

    Figure 1-3. Figure 1-3 . depicts key environmental variables. They may be general forces and trends within the natural or societal environments or specific factors that operate. within an organization's specific task environment—often called its industry.
  • 2 Peter -

    2 Peter -

    "Peter penned the most sublime language of any of the apostles."Joseph Smith, History of the Church, 5:392 ... spirit of fear; but of power, and of love, and of a sound mind. Be not thou therefore ashamed of the testimony...
  • Gene Sleuths - Community Resources for Problem Solving in Biology

    Gene Sleuths - Community Resources for Problem Solving in Biology

    Gene Sleuthing Lorraine Sartori Majid Masso Paul R. McCreary
  • Essentials of Sociology: A Down-To-Earth Approach

    Essentials of Sociology: A Down-To-Earth Approach

    The Economy: Historical OverviewLearning Objective 12.1: Summarize historical changes to the economy. The economy operates in a predictable manner. Goods and services ensure survival, make life easier, and contribute to social identity. Economies of modern high-income nations are the result...