Female genital mutilation in Europe: challenges to prevention

Female genital mutilation in Europe: challenges to prevention

THE STATUS OF FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION PREVENTION IN EUROPE AND A LOOK TOWARD THE FUTURE Anna Powers Advisor: Dr. Tomas Griebling Mentor: Natalie Kontoulis Summer 2015 Project Objectives To gather information from European nonprofit organizations that focus on female genital mutilation (FGM) prevention about: o The organizations structures

o FGM laws and statistics in the countries where the organizations are located o Challenges the organizations face in preventing FGM and strategies for overcoming those challenges To provide a brief US comparison of nonprofit work with FGM prevention The END FGM European Network The End FGM European network (END FGM) is a European umbrella organization set up by 11 national NGOs to ensure sustainable European action to end FGM.

Five point strategy consisting of health, data collection, integrating FGM into broader measures on violence against women, protecting asylum seekers and refugees affected by, or at risk of, FGM, and including FGM in the EUs engagements with the rest of the world Above: Adriana Bertini with her creation, Mother

and Child, at Auction for Action Above: Vice President of European Commission Viviane Reding receiving the Campaigns recommendations and a creation by Brazilian artist Adriana Bertini BACKGROUND

INFORMATION Motivation In the nineteenth century, the central moral challenge was slavery. In the twentieth century, it was the battle against totalitarianism. We believe that in this century the paramount moral challenge will be the struggle for gender equality around the world. --Nicholas Kristof & Sheryl WuDunn, Half the Sky What is FGM/FGC/FC? According to the World Health

Organization, FGM comprises all procedures that involve partial or total removal of the external female genitalia, or other injury to the female genital organs for non-medical reasons. There are four major types. More than 125 million girls and women alive today have been cut. FGM is mostly carried out on young girls sometime between infancy and age 15. Mostly carried out by traditional circumcisers, who often play other

central roles in communities. However, more than 18% of all FGM is performed by health care providers, and the trend towards medicalization is increasing. Depending on the type of FGM, the procedure can take 20-30 minutes. Sharp objects, including knives, glass, sharpened stones, and hot coals, are used to make the cuts. In most cases the instrument used to make the cuts is used on

multiple girls and is not cleaned in between uses In most cases anesthetics and antiseptics are not used Reasons for FGM Religion Sociological: Rite of Passage Cleanliness & Purity Psychological Sexual & Marriage Factors Economic Tradition

Consequences of FGM Immediate: Long-Term: Shock Bleeding and hemorrhage Infection Damage to organs

Urinary Tract Infections Extremely painful menstruation Scars and keloid on the vulva Fistula Vulvar abscesses Severe pain during intercourse Complications during child birth,

potentially leading to obstructed labor and fetal death or brain damage Infertility Blood clots in the uterus and/or vagina Psychological Problems, including depression and anxiety FGM & Migration To date, there is no data collection which would allow for comparison and a European wide vision of the exact extent of the practice of FGM in Europe or of the number of women and girls living in Europe at risk of FGM. According to a resolution passed by the European Parliament in March 2009 on Combating FGM in the EU around 500,000 women and girls living in Europe have

been subjected to female genital mutilation and 180,000 are at risk for it each year. More than half a million women and girls are at risk of undergoing or have already undergone FGM in the United States (Population Reference Bureau) Ethical Considerations Cultural relativism vs. universality of human rights Increasingly complicated as migrant communities bring FGM to countries outside of where the tradition is originally practiced. The practice violates an individual's rights to health, security and physical integrity, the right to be free from torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, and the right to life when the procedure results in death. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), Convention Against Torture,

Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW) and Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) PROJECT METHODS & RESULTS Methods Survey administered to twelve nonprofit organizations associated with the END FGM network. All organizations had some prevention component. Questions assessed: The Organizations Structure Core Area of Work FGM Prevention Programs Programs in Africa

African Employees Year of Creation Building Bridges Program FGM laws and statistics in the country where the organization is located National laws in the organizations country Whether or not the organizations country signed/ratified the Istanbul Convention Studies on Prevalence and girls at risk in the organizations country Populations the organization reached Challenges Strategies Core Area of Work? Is FGM your Organization's Core Area of Work?

Yes No 5; 41.67% 7; 58.33% N u m b e r o f O rg a n iz a t io n s Prevention Programs 9

8 7 6 5 4 3 2

1 0 Programs in Africa? Does your Organization have Programs in Africa? 5; 41.67% 7; 58.33% Yes No

Composition of Staff Are 50% or more of your Organizations Staff Members from Countries that Practice FGM? Yes No 4; 33.33% 8; 66.67% What Populations do you Reach? Does your Organization work with Women from all of the top 5 Countries of Origin that Women at Risk for FGM in your Country are from?

Yes No 5; 41.67% 7; 58.33% N u m b e r o f O rg a n iz a tio n s Year of Creation 2 1

0 1967 1982 1983 1990 1994

1995 Year 1996 2000 2001 2009 2014

National Laws against FGM? Does the Country in which your Organization is located have National Laws against FGM? Yes No 12; 100.00% The Istanbul Convention Did the Country in which your Organization is located Sign the Istanbul Convention (on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women)

2; 16.67% Did the Country in which your Organization is located Ratify the Istanbul Convention (on Preventing and Combating Violence against Women) Yes No Yes No 6; 50.00% 10; 83.33%

6; 50.00% Studies on Prevalence and at Risk Girls? Does the Country in which your Organization is located have a Study to estimate the Prevalence of Women with FGM in the Country? Yes No 4; 33.33% 8; 66.67% Does the Country in which your Organization is located have a Study to estimate the Number of Girls at Risk for FGM in the Country?

Yes No 3; 25.00 % 9; 75.00 % Challenges Organizations That cited the challenge

Challenges to preventing FGM IN EUROPE 5: APF, MIGS, EquiPop, GAMS Belgium, AkiDwa Reaching/gaining access to migrant communities in Europe 4: FORWARD, INTACT, GAMS Belgium, FSAN European professionals often know little about FGM and are reluctant to work on FGM because they feel uncomfortable; professionals include healthcare workers, religious leaders, politicians, and legal workers.

3: Female Integrity, EquiPop, FORWARD, Getting immigrant groups to accept that FGM is a harmful practice and a legitimate problem, especially in light of other challenges they face like financial struggles. 3: FORWARD, FSAN, GAMS Belgium Lack of government funding. As a result, programs are largely project based and lack continuance. 2: Medicos del Mundo, INTACT

It is difficult for female migrants to get asylum based on FGM in European countries. 2: AkiDwa, FORWARD European media coverage of FGM is often sensationalist and negative (linked with anti-migrant discourse), which discourages anti-FGM sentiment and action in these countries. 1: AkiDwa European society in general has a lack of knowledge about

FGM; challenging to provide quick, relevant information to the public. 1: APF Little information about the state of FGM in European countries: number of women in Europe who have undergone FGM, number of girls/women at risk for FGM, etc. 1: Medicos del Mundo Overcoming the social pressure migrants often face to undergo FGM/have their daughters undergo FGM when they visit their

country of origin. 1: EquiPop Connecting migrants with behavioral changes occurring in their country of origin. 1: FORWARD Lack of collaboration between NGOS focused on womens issues and FGM within each country and Europe in general. 1: GAMS Belgium

Teams that focus on FGM prevention are often diverse (from many different countries). Members have different opinions on many issues, which can make finding a common direction difficult. Reaching/Gaining Access to Migrant Communities in Europe Mapping migrant organizations Community health ambassadors/community mediators (migrant women from practicing communities who engage their communities in dialogue around FGM and who disseminate information within their local communities)

Professionals Lack of Knowledge Hold workshops for professionals on FGM A need to develop better educational tools and ensure implementation of those tools Getting Immigrant Groups to accept FGM as a Legitimate Problem Talk with doctors and nurses about FGM and educating patients on its harms Giving monetary compensation to involved migrants and mobilizing during nonworking hours Sensitization Lack of Funding Aim for a diverse source of funding, including partnerships with coalitions and other

organizations, to avoid relying on one major source A need for better structural financing from the government in most European countries (at least 3 year funding intervals) US Comparison Conclusions Most European prevention programs focus on educating professionals and FGM practicing communities Most European nonprofits do not reach all FGM practicing communities in their country Top challenges to prevention of FGM in Europe include accessing migrant communities, professionals lack of knowledge about FGM, lack of funding, difficulty

getting asylum, and sensationalist media coverage The United States has a less developed network of FGM organizations working to prevent FGM and can learn from Europe as it continues to address FGM. Acknowledgements Natalie Kontoulis, Communications and Network Officer at the END FGM European Network Dr. Fabienne Richard, Executive Director of GAMS Belgium The END FGM European Network Dr. Tomas Griebling Resources World Health Organization END FGM Fact Sheet (

http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/) END FGM European Network Website (http://www.endfgm.eu/en/) Half the Sky by Nicholas Kristof and Sheryl WuDunn The African Womens Organization Training Kit: Prevention and Elimination of Female Genital Mutilation among Immigrants in Europe Council of Europe Istanbul Convention Website (http:// www.coe.int/en/web/istanbul-convention)

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Sickle Cell Anemia in Job Corps

    Sickle Cell Anemia in Job Corps

    History of sickle cell disease (SCD). Present in Africa for at least 5,000years. 1910-Discovered in US. Walter Clement Noel - dental student from Grenada studying in Chicago. Dr. James B. Herrick - Not interested in Noel's symptoms as Herrick was...
  • Writing Routine and Positive Messages - Anvari.Net

    Writing Routine and Positive Messages - Anvari.Net

    Writing Routine and Positive Messages. ... (LO 3) Outline an effective strategy for writing routine replies and positive messages. ... the company offers its fan community something of value—a playlist of relaxing piano music as a Monday mood booster. The...
  • Criminal Law - the-eye.eu

    Criminal Law - the-eye.eu

    Criminal Law A2 Mrs Howe
  • A Brief History of the Earth - Biology Junction

    A Brief History of the Earth - Biology Junction

    The Burninator Eocene period - 50 million years Eocene period - 50 million years Oligocene - 32 million years Miocene - 10 million years Pleistocene - 19,000 years ago A Brief History of the Earth Timescale 7/8 of the entire...
  • Calcolo combinatorio Prof.ssa Angela Fanti Liceo Scientifico Statale

    Calcolo combinatorio Prof.ssa Angela Fanti Liceo Scientifico Statale

    Ancora! L'Egitto era decisamente la Compostela dei matematici. A quell'epoca, quando ci s'interessava di matematica, la conoscenza dell'arabo era un vantaggio enorme. Omar si era fatto chiamare al-Khayyam, figlio del venditore di tende; Leonardo si contentò di farsi chiamare «...
  • Integrative Biophysics and Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Therapy

    Integrative Biophysics and Pulsed Electromagnetic Field Therapy

    Pulsed Electromagnetic Field (PEMF) Therapy as an instrument of integrative biophysics. Biomolecular effects. Epigenetic effects. Cellular physiologic effects. Optimal tissue frequencies. Proof of efficacy via peer reviewed studies, including RDBPC clinical trials. Ondamed® as a powerful instrument of integrative biophysics.
  • Polychotomizers: One-Hot Vectors, Softmax, and Cross-Entropy

    Polychotomizers: One-Hot Vectors, Softmax, and Cross-Entropy

    Derivative of cross-entropy w.r.t. network weights. Putting it all together: a one-layer softmax neural net. Outline. Dichotomizers and Polychotomizers. ... So, hey, let's take the logarithm, to get rid of that nasty product operation.
  • Determinants of Health: Income Inequality and Mental Health

    Determinants of Health: Income Inequality and Mental Health

    Does poverty cause problems or do problems cause poverty? (social causation vs. social selection) 8/28/2014. Poverty is not good for children's present or future mental health.3-month prevalence of one or more DSM-IV psychiatric disorders in poor/non-poor* children (poverty= low SES)2...