DNA - Bridgewater State University

DNA - Bridgewater State University

DNA INTRODUCTION WHAT IS DNA? deoxyribonucleic acid no 2 people can have the same DNA, except identical twins. the chance of this kind of evidence being wrong is 1 in 10 million. How is DNA obtained from

a crime scene? blood Hair Semen Saliva bone (marrow) Flesh Urine teeth (pulp)

DNA AND THE LAW Issue: can the law keep up with technology? Can suspects be compelled to provide samples, and how those samples will be taken? Do you need a warrant? 4th amendment unreasonable search & seizure (history & today)

Reasonable suspicion What crimes are considered under such a warrant? Non-forensic applications recently used in Ottawa to identify 2 identical twins who had been adopted and accidentally separated at birth. Paternity cases Most powerful uses are in the CJ system

DNA in law enforcement In violent crimes, hair, blood and semen samples are more common than fingerprint evidence. true for sexual assault cases. investigations go much quicker. help implicate the guilty, would eliminate the innocent data base which could include all DNA of convicted sex/violent offenders

DNA in homicide cases could be used to help identify a murder weapon. For example, a knife with blood stains. used to distinguish "copy cat" crimes from serial crimes.

connect crimes committed by the same offender, i.e. serial murders. determine if more than one offender was involved identify deceased/missing persons. THE LEGAL QUESTIONS OF DNA EVIDENCE The legal question of taking a blood sample from an accused person who does not

consent is a critical issue. Is it a form of self-incrimination, or does it constitute an unreasonable search? Consider a similar case: When people are pulled over on suspicion of impaired driving, they are required to give a sample of their breath. If the suspect refuses to give a sample, he/she can be charged. Differences between drunk driving & homicide the more serious a crime is, the heavier the sentence and the

greater the stigma. Therefore, the courts may be more stringent on the issues of constitutional rights. Standard of proof Another issue in DNA search warrants is the determination of a standard or threshold of proof to justify the taking of a sample from an accused.

The standard is usually reasonable and probable grounds. For example, an officer may see some erratic driving, smell alcohol on the suspect's breath, etc. But, DNA testing is more complicated, and may warrant a higher standard. DNA vs. fingerprinting When people are arrested, they are required to undergo fingerprinting.

is not an unwarranted invasion of privacy. SOME CANADIAN CASES: R. v. Alderton R. v. Legere Getting the DNA sample the police have had to resort to some pretty imaginative means to try to get DNA samples from suspects

obtaining a tissue that an individual has used to blow his nose and thrown away Retrieving shed hair Ryan Love case INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE WITH DNA EVIDENCE

ENGLAND In 1983 15 year old girl was raped and murdered. In July, 1986, second murder Richard Buckland confessed. DNA tests showed that the same man killed both girls, but Buckland was not that man The police asked the 5500 men in the area to give DNA sample. All gave samples except for a man named Colin Pitchfork Florida V. Andrew

The first case in the United States to use DNA the accused was convicted of over 20 cases of sexual assault or attempted sexual assault. There have even been cases where the accused requested a DNA test only to have it reveal his guilt. POSSIBLE PROBLEMS WITH DNA EVIDENCE Critics of DNA worry that the police may

over rely on DNA evidence. The following problems can arise with DNA evidence. Contamination problems: Heat, humidity, moisture, decomposition of a body, time since death, temperature where body was stored Sexual assault cases: the absence of semen does not mean that there was no sexual assault. great cost and time consumption. DATABANKS

The DNA of convicted sex offenders and other violent offenders could be stored into computers which would then be accessible to police forces could provide the ability to do split second searches and comparisons. would be similar in theory to the Automated Fingerprint I.D. System Databanks will assist the police in 3 areas:

1. open cases 2. missing persons/unidentified deceased victims 3. convicted offenders BUT.Civil liberty issues? what information will be stored? which offences require an offender

to be in the computer? who will have access to the information, and for what purpose. ? Need for DNA standards People v. Castro. The accused had murdered his neighbor and her 2 year old daughter. State of Minnesota v. Schwartz The accused was charged with the first degree murder of a stabbing

victim.

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Why Five? - Intergon

    Why Five? - Intergon

    1981 to 1990 Intergon Principal Consultant 1990 to 1992 KPMG Senior Consultant 1992 to 1995 CPG Corporate Quality Manager Consultant to Telstra Software Development Consultant to Telstra Data Centre Operations 1995 to 2007 Intergon Principal Consultant RMIT MBA student PhD...
  • EPA Region 9 Water Quality Assessment Report Tutorial

    EPA Region 9 Water Quality Assessment Report Tutorial

    (your mouse should look like a small hand pointer) to make it disappear. Try clicking on the links/boxes above. Make sure your mouse looks like when you place your mouse over the link, to make sure you are clicking on...
  • Journey Through Innovation

    Journey Through Innovation

    Introductions. Tax Collector. Honorable Ruth Pietruszewski, CFC. Data Department. Marc Villanova, Assistant Manager. Ron Medellin, Programmer. Glenn Blume, Programmer ...
  • Jupiter and Saturn - Our Shades of Blue Inc.

    Jupiter and Saturn - Our Shades of Blue Inc.

    Cassini snaps a photo of Earth. On 7/19/2013, earthlings were told to go outside and wave at the sky. Cassini took the photo. Shall we zoom in?
  • Shots, Angles, Color, Placement: The Things We Forget to Teach

    Shots, Angles, Color, Placement: The Things We Forget to Teach

    Eye-level Angle. With an eye-level angle, the camera is eye-level with the subject. Everyone is on an equal playing level. This angle is the most-often used in film-making (and often the only angle used in student's attempts at a film).
  • State of the art in FPGA technology - Merlintec

    State of the art in FPGA technology - Merlintec

    State of the art in FPGA technology ... First CPLD (1988) Sells US$1.2B/year Xilinx vs Altera High End = Virtex 1998 1999 E 2000 II 2002 II Pro 2004 4 LX/SX/FX 2006 5 LX/LXT/SXT 2008 5 FXT/TXT 2009 6 High...
  • Anemia - pagingdrbrittniblog.files.wordpress.com

    Anemia - pagingdrbrittniblog.files.wordpress.com

    Wilms tumor . e) Wilms tumor. The correct answer is Option (E), Wilms tumor, because the clinical presentation of hematuria, abdominal pain of two months' duration, and a palpable mass in the right upper quadrant of the abdomen is characteristic...
  • Parkinson's disease - Wake County Public School System

    Parkinson's disease - Wake County Public School System

    Parkinson's disease is a progressive disorder that affects the nervous system. Most cases of Parkinson's disease result from a complex interaction of environmental and genetic factors, but exactly why Parkinson's occurs and how the neurons become impaired is unknown.