Constitutions and Institutions - Memorial University of ...

Constitutions and Institutions - Memorial University of ...

Constitutions and Institutions How do they operate? What difference do they make in liberal democracies? Some questions: What difference do constitutions make? Are constitutions scraps of paper, as Bismarck argued? OR Do constitutions spell out relationships between different institutions, e.g. Between parliament and the executive? Between central and provincial governments?

A quick refresher: varieties of political systems Liberal democracies: Canada Britain France Germany United States Semidemocracies: Russia Ukraine ?

Egypt Algeria Serbia Authoritarian systems: China Iraq ?? Iran Saudi Arabia North Korea Unitary vs. federal systems: Unitary system -- sovereignty concentrated in a

central government: Power may be devolved to regional governments, created by the central government But devolved powers can be withdrawn (e.g. Northern Ireland) Federal system: sovereignty shared by a central government and provincial governments -- neither is capable of abolishing the other Presidential v. Parliamentary v. semi-presidential systems Presidential system: political executive is separate from the legislature

Parliamentary system: the political executive must serve with the support (or at a minimum, the forbearance) of a majority of the lower house of parliament Semi-presidential system: combines features of both: Directly elected president Premier, typically appointed by the president, must serve with the confidence of the parliament Forms of liberal democracies (and semi-democracies) Parliamentary SemiPresidential Presidential

Unitary UK France Uruguay Federal Canada Germany Australia

Russia US Mexico Four cases: Britain: Unitary parliamentary Germany: Federal Parliamentary

France: Unitary Semipresidential United States: Federal Presidential An argument: Constitutions matter, and matter a great deal, when political leaders follow them: Courts increasingly enforce constitutions But we need to look not only at the constitution on paper, but the way in which it is brought off paper and how it evolves

Valid not only for liberal democracies, but also semi-democracies and some authoritarian political systems Reasons for this: (a preliminary take) Institutions (and the shape they take) matter: Institutions shape the ways in which political forces are expressed and channelled, in particular some of the demands which end up on the political agenda the ease with which conflicts can be resolved Example: variation ways in which regional and

cultural differences are expressed and dealt with in federal and unity systems Variations in power of political executives UK: Unwritten constitution Parliamentary system: Prime Minister and Cabinet serve with the confidence of parliament Because the single member plurality electoral system usually manufactures majorities, the government usually has the support of a parliamentary majority

Some questions: How powerful are the political executives in different forms of liberal democracies? What role do assemblies play? Are legislative assemblies capable of controlling political executives? If so how? What differences do parties and party systems make? What difference does federalism make?

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Construct-asnowflake What do all snowflakes have in common?

    Construct-asnowflake What do all snowflakes have in common?

    Construct-a-snowflake Draw in the 6 lines of symmetry Construct-a-snowflake Now design half a point of your snowflake Construct-a-snowflake And finally, use tracing paper to reflect it across the mirror lines Construct-a-snowflake Your snowflake will look great against a brightly coloured...
  • Maths in Action :: Exam Technique Dr J

    Maths in Action :: Exam Technique Dr J

    But what the devil is that maths doing? Each preposition in the English language, such as 'behind', 'between', 'near', 'left of', has a probabilistic model built for it.
  • Making Thinking Visible

    Making Thinking Visible

    Our first routine, aka strategy is Think-Puzzle-Explore. In each of the routines, except What Makes You Say That?, it will be important to document student responses. Documentation is defined as the practice of observing, recording, interpreting, and sharing, through a...
  • Workforce Readiness | Entrepreneurship | Financial Literacy Welcome

    Workforce Readiness | Entrepreneurship | Financial Literacy Welcome

    All of Junior Achievement's programs are made possible through the time and commitment of JA volunteers who make a true impact in the lives of students. "The best part are the Junior Achievement volunteers, like Anita, who take time to...
  • Day 34: Launching the New Ship of State 1789-1800

    Day 34: Launching the New Ship of State 1789-1800

    France viewed Jay's Treaty as a step toward alliance with Britain. Violated the Franco-American Treaty of 1778. Seized American merchant vessels. Attempted to meet with Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-XYZ affair. Identify the impacts of the XYZ affair. Navy Department-3 ship...

    65 y/o man presents with a 2 month history of fatigue and weight loss. FBC shows he has a haemoglobin of 60g/l (normal 130-180g/l) What does this tell you? The Peer Teaching Society is not liable for false or misleading...
  • Trofic regulation and spatial structuring of the pelagic ...

    Trofic regulation and spatial structuring of the pelagic ...

    BarEcoRe WP1 . Fish and benthos communities, past changes and regime shifts Edda Johannesen Maria Fossheim, Lis Lindal Jørgensen, Elena Eriksen Thomas de Lange Wenneck, Herdis Langøy, Trond Thangstad BarEcoRe (Barents Sea Ecosystem Resilience under global environmental change) aim at...
  • San Jose Announcements - ACN Inc.

    San Jose Announcements - ACN Inc.

    Standalone High Speed Internet Important Things to Remember! Confirmation and communication of High Speed Internet availability may take up to 2 business days to communicate to the customer In some areas, ACN High Speed Internet may not be available even...