Assessing Speech Intelligibility and Severity

Assessing Speech Intelligibility and Severity

Assessing Speech Intelligibility and Severity What are some standard procedures? Are measures of intelligibility and severity the same? Although judgements about intelligibility and severity may be correlated, they represent two

different indices about an individuals speech For example, a child may have a severe resonance disorder, but his/ her speech is still intelligible Intelligibility Scales

Typically a panel of 2-5 listeners (expert ~ novice; familiar ~ unfamiliar) rate a taped (audio or video) segment of childs speech Rank intelligibility of childs speech compared to age peers Scales typically use 3-point or 5point judgment scales (See Bleile) scores are averaged to derive a composite intelligibility rating score Intelligibility Scales

Kent, Miolo, & Bloedel (1994) compared 19 intelligibility measures according to 5 categories that differed with regard to the emphasis of the analysis (phonetic ~ phonemic; word level ~ conversation) Intelligibility Scales Listed 8 factors that influence clinical evaluation of intelligibility:

loss of phonological contrasts loss of contrasts in specific environments extent of homonymy amt of difference between target~realization frequency of occurrence in English

consistency familiarity of listener with speaker context in which communication occurs Intelligibility Weston & Shriberg (1992) concluded that articulation variables alone cannot account for all the breakdowns that result in communication other general contextual and linguistic variables are related to

speech intelligibility Severity Similar to intelligibility rating scales, a panel of familiar or unfamiliar listeners judge a segment of a childs recorded (audio or video-taped) speech (single word or connected speech) Severity

Perceptual scales (see Bleile) or quantitative measures 4 Point Clinical Judgement Scale of Severity No disorder-Mild-Moderate-Severe average score of 3.5 often required to provide clinical services Severity Quantitative Measures PCC (and 8 variations)

Hodsons PDS Edwards PDI Comparison of PCC and PDS Severity Ratings PCC PDS Mild >90% Mild

1-19 pts Mild-Mod 65-85% Moderate 20-39 Mod-Sev 50-65% Severe

40-59 Severe <50% Profound 60+ Shriberg, Austin, Lewis, McSweeny, & Wilson (1997) 9 speech metrics

PCC (based on conv speech) PCC-A (common clinical distortions scored correct) PCC-R ([un]common distortion scored correct) ACI (differentially weighs distortion ~ sub/omis) PCI (percentage of sounds mastered-early talkers) PVC (similar to PCC, but for vowels/diphthongs) PVC-R (similar to PCC-R, but for vowels/diphthongs) PPC (percentage to consonants/vowels correct) PPC-R (scores distortions correct) Which metric is most appropriate? Depends on specific needs of the assessment Interest limited to consonants

PCC, PCC-A, PCC-R, ACI Young/severely delayed children PCI Interest in vowels/diphthongs PVC, PVC-R Interest in articulation competence on all speech sounds PPC, PPC-R Rafaat, Rvachew, & Russell (1995)

Purpose of study was to determine the percentage of agreement between SLPs in rating PI severity Adequate reliability for older children (4;6+), but unreliable for children under 3;6 Unable to reliably distinguish TD from mild delay Why were SLPs less reliable on severity

ratings of younger children? What factors account for differences in reliability ratings?

Recently Viewed Presentations

  • Lecture 5: Log-Linear Modeling, Or How You&#x27;ll Learn to Love ...

    Lecture 5: Log-Linear Modeling, Or How You'll Learn to Love ...

    Virtual Manipulatives. National Library of Virtual Manipulatives (NLVM); see Clements and McMillen (1996), and Moyer (2002) In NLP: Parsing board game (van Halteren, 2002)
  • Peer Interaction Effectively, yet Infrequently, Enables ...

    Peer Interaction Effectively, yet Infrequently, Enables ...

    Peer Interaction Effectively, yet Infrequently, Enables Programmers to Discover New Tools. Emerson Murphy-Hill. North Carolina State University. Gail Murphy. University of British Columbia
  • Determine your role in a managed service

    Determine your role in a managed service

    Customer Specific Activities, Supported by Partner, enhanced by Microsoft Life Cycle Services. Application. Define, develop and operate business process. Define, develop, test and operate Customizations. Monitor and Manage Non Production Deployments (Dev/Build/Sandbox) Manage Application Updates, Customization Quality and Updates. Application...
  • Foundations of Strategy Chapter 8: Global Strategies and the ...

    Foundations of Strategy Chapter 8: Global Strategies and the ...

    Transnational Organization. Each national unit is a source of ideas, skills, and capabilities that can be harnessed for the benefit of the total organization.
  • Gonioscopy

    Gonioscopy

    Are yet to replace Gonioscopy for angle assessment. Definition: Gonioscopy is a clinical technique used to examine structures in the anterior chamber angle. Trantas, using limbal indentation in an eye with keratoglobus in 1907, first visualized the anterior chamber angle...
  • Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint

    Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint

    Judicial Activism and Judicial Restraint Objective 29h By Stephanie Byrnes 4-22-08 Pd. 5 Objective 29h- recognize the difference between judicial activism and judicial restraint Judicial Activism Judicial activism is the term used to describe the actions of judges who go...
  • One to One Communication…. - Colorado FFA

    One to One Communication…. - Colorado FFA

    Ag Communications One to One Communication One to One Communication Communicating with one other person One to One Communication Face to Face Conversations Telephone Calls Interviews Verbal Aspects Conversation- talking about various matters of interest to both parties, these are...
  • Methods for Summarizing the Evidence: Meta-Analyses and Pooled

    Methods for Summarizing the Evidence: Meta-Analyses and Pooled

    Meta-Analyses and Pooled Analyses Donna Spiegelman, Sc.D. Departments of Epidemiology and Biostatistics ... Microsoft Graph 97 Chart CorelEquation! 2.0 Equation MathType 6.0 Equation Microsoft Word Document Methods for Summarizing the Evidence: Meta-Analyses and Pooled Analyses Methods for ...